Nestled in the heart of New Glarus, Wisconsin, Sugar River Pizza Co stands as a beloved local institution, offering a comforting and authentic dining experience centered around exceptional pizza. Located conveniently at 700 Railroad St, this establishment has become more than just a place to eat; it is a community gathering spot where quality ingredients meet time-honored preparation methods. For residents and visitors alike exploring the charming Swiss heritage of New Glarus, a stop at Sugar River Pizza Co provides a delicious anchor to their day.
The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between casual and welcoming, making it suitable for everything from a quick family dinner to a relaxed evening out with friends. While the menu features a variety of appealing options, the true star remains the pizza—crafted with care and baked to perfection. Understanding what makes this local favorite tick reveals a commitment to quality that resonates through every slice served.
What sets Sugar River Pizza Co apart in a landscape often crowded with chain restaurants? It’s the dedication to crafting a superior product while maintaining a genuine connection to the community it serves. This focus on local flavor and high standards is evident in their approach to ingredients and service, creating a dining experience that feels both familiar and special.
Key Highlights of the Sugar River Pizza Co Experience
When considering a visit to this New Glarus staple, several aspects consistently draw patrons back time and again. These elements define the unique appeal of Sugar River Pizza Co:
Commitment to Quality Ingredients: The foundation of any great pizza lies in its components. Sugar River Pizza Co emphasizes sourcing high-quality ingredients, ensuring that the crust, sauce, and toppings combine harmoniously. This dedication to freshness and flavor elevates their offerings beyond the standard fare, providing a noticeable difference in taste and texture that discerning pizza lovers appreciate.
Authentic Local Atmosphere: Situated right on Railroad St, the restaurant embodies the relaxed, friendly spirit of New Glarus. The dining environment is designed to be comfortable and unpretentious, fostering an atmosphere where conversations flow easily and everyone feels like a regular. It’s a place where the focus remains squarely on good food and good company.
Mastery of Pizza Craftsmanship: Beyond just assembling ingredients, there is a clear skill involved in how the pizzas are prepared, from the dough consistency to the precise baking time. This attention to the technical aspects of pizza making results in consistently well-executed pies, whether you prefer classic combinations or something more adventurous from their menu selections.
A True Community Hub: More than just a commercial venture, Sugar River Pizza Co functions as an integral part of the local social fabric. It serves as a reliable destination for celebrations, casual weeknight meals, and a place where neighbors connect. This deep integration into the New Glarus community adds a layer of warmth and authenticity to the overall dining proposition.
These core strengths—quality ingredients, a genuine local feel, expert preparation, and community focus—combine to create a compelling reason for anyone in or near New Glarus, WI 53574, to stop by 700 Railroad St. It’s an establishment that understands that the best dining experiences are built on consistency and heart.
Concluding Thoughts on Your Visit
Sugar River Pizza Co represents the best of small-town American dining: straightforward, delicious, and deeply rooted in its location. It offers a dependable culinary refuge where the simple pleasure of a perfectly made pizza is celebrated. Whether you are passing through Green County or live just down the street, this restaurant promises a satisfying meal delivered with genuine local hospitality. Take the time to experience what makes this particular spot on Railroad Street a cherished landmark for pizza enthusiasts in the region. It is a testament to how dedication to craft can turn a simple meal into a memorable occasion.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Outdoor seating
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in
Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great wine list
Live music
Serves local specialty
Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy-hour drinks
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine
Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service
Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy
Crowd
Family friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safe space
Planning
Accepts reservations
Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Pets
Dogs allowed outside
Menus
Photos
Reviews Sugar River Pizza Co New Glarus
john lovetinsky
22-12-2025
Up there with the best pizza I've ever had. Very fresh ingredients. I easily could have eaten the whole thing. Owner is personable. I would order from them regularly if they were closer.
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Group size
3-4 people
Vegetarian offerings
Not sure
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot
S F
23-10-2025
Stopped here for a late lunch after the New Glarus Brewery. Ordered pepitas (fried dough covered in cheese and bacon + ranch on the side) for an appetizer -- soft, chewy, and flavorful -- followed by taco pizza. The taco pizza was excellent and we loved that we could add our own toppings. Great food!
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Recommended dishes
Jeff Osterhaus
14-10-2025
My family ordered pizza online so it would be there when we got there, gave a 20% tip and they refused to let us eat at the restaurant. … More
C. E.
09-10-2025
A well placed pizza place that is family owned and run, as we were seated by the owner, who was very nice and our waiteess was her daughter, also very nice and funny. I loved the open seating and it definitely attracts a crowd on the … More
Pat Tasker - Your Local Market Expert
20-09-2025
After a successful bridal gown shopping spree down the street at Brandi’s Bridal, our group of grandmas, moms, and bridesmaids made the natural next stop—Sugar River Pizza in New Glarus! 🍕👰💍
Apparently, we had the look—the manager clocked us as a post-bridal-shopping crew the second we walked in. (Turns out, that’s a thing here!) 😂
We grabbed a big table and dove into some seriously good eats. The cheese bread? Golden, gooey, and gone in seconds. The fried cheese curds? A Wisconsin must. And the drink selection kept everyone happy.
But let’s talk about the pizza—the crust was that perfect combo of doughy and crisp, and the toppings were anything but basic. Our table shared the “Mac Daddy” (think bacon cheeseburger on a pizza—yes, it’s as good as it sounds) and a creamy Chicken Alfredo pizza the ladies couldn’t stop raving about. 🍗🧄🥓🧅
Nice interior and even nicer patio dining for summer days! Street parking and walkable to other fun shops in town!
Great food, fun service, and a memorable way to toast a bride-to-be. Highly recommend this spot for any celebratory group—or just because you love a good pizza! 🍻💒🍕. The town is so cute I wished I had more time to shop at more of the local stores! Made me decide to come back for a weekend soon!
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Reservation
Not sure
Group size
Suitable for all group sizes
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free street parking
Andy Fallon (LT Fallon)
17-09-2025
Good pizza. Been here two times for pizza. Fun place and good food. We like the thin crust.
Food:…
More
Nicole Wittkopp
30-08-2025
Handmade, fresh, absolutely delicious pizza!! Very impressed with everything we ordered! Pizza was amazing- even the wheat crust pizza was amazing!! Clearly take pride in the food. And very friendly service. Extensive beer and wine menu too. Will be back ASAP.
Katie Dunham
29-08-2025
Food is okay and service was fine but it was SO COLD in here!! We had to go back out to the car and get a blanket and an extra coat for my toddler because he started shivering. We overheard them say the thermostat was 52 degrees. Everyone in the place was wearing a coat. We asked to sit upstairs hoping it was warmer but they said there was only one waitress so we had to sit downstairs. My whole party is wearing coats and hats and shivering.
Food: 4
Service: 4
Atmosphere: 1
Andy Fallon (LT Fallon)
20-08-2025
Good pizza. Been here two times for pizza. Fun place and good food. We like the thin crust.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Lynn Retzlaff
31-07-2025
What an excellent pizza place! I am allergic to wheat and they have a great wheat/gluten-free option for crust. The weight staff is incredibly helpful, kind, and just the right amount of hospitality allowing you to enjoy your food and company while making sure you have everything you need. My daughter and I had such a great meal and enjoyed the staff so much that I pulled the manager aside to let him know. He has a great group of young people working.
There was traditional and creative options for pizza as well. Bravo! I would definitely recommend.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
1 person, 2 people, 3-4 people
Dietary restrictions
I am allergic to wheat and they had a great gluten-free pizza crust. They were very assuring, kind and helpful when it came to caring for my specific dietary needs. The wait staff is top-notch.
Parking
The only constructive criticism I would give is to suggest a deep cleaning as sitting at our booth, the walls and trim and eating area was a bit grungy. The table itself was clean. That being said, I’m not going to rate them down for that because the rest of the experience made up for it and my house could use a good deep cleaning as well so who am I to judge! 😉😊
Kid-friendliness
I was there with my daughter, but she is a young adult. There were other patrons with their children, and I would definitely consider it kid friendly.
M D
26-07-2025
Sorry, I did not intend to leave a review and must have hit 1 star on accident. The food was fine but but I'm pretty sure the waiter forgot to put in our order. It took over an hour to get our pizza and we never got our appetizer. He was nice though. More
Nick
05-07-2025
Very good food I am a hot mess Pizza very delicious 10 out of 10
Service…
More
Jim Modrak
26-06-2025
We stopped in again on 10/19/24 And had Sierra as our server. Again everything was great!! I had the BBQ pulled pork on flatbread and my wife had lasagna soup which was very good and super filling. It is nice to find a place you can look forward to going to and Sugar River Pizza is that place!
My wife and I are here again 7/8/2023 and nothing has changed. Everything was great and our server Rita made sure we had what we needed and made a great beverage recommendation to my wife! We love the Sugar River State trail and love Sugar River Pizza that's right on the trail.
My wife and I ate here on Saturday 7/23/2022. We were seated right away and our waitress Sierra was very prompt and attentive. We had the Garden Belle pizza and it was delicious for sure. Some may have found the crust a little over done but I was fine with it.
We ate outside on the covered patio and the music was relaxing and not to loud. As far as the prices go I feel they were well within line with other establishments and not over priced in any way.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Haylee Browning
21-06-2025
I went in yesterday with my boyfriend for dinner last night and had an awesome meal! We got the cheese curds for an appetizer and they reminded me of the kind you would get at the fair. Light and airy batter and absolutely delicious. Then we got a meat lovers pizza that we demolished. The meat on the pizza was cooked perfectly and the dough was so good! Also, our waitress (The tallish blonde one) was an absolute sweetheart! 10/10 would recommend and definitely make the almost hour drive to.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Dinner
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Majestic Miles Travel
10-06-2025
This place is top-notch. We live in Galina, illinois, and I would say this is a top five restaurant in all our travels, the pizza and the chicken parmesan are our favorite and are so tasty. Phil is a awesome server you can tell he takes his job very serious. He is awesome. Deb the owner stoped by and said hi thank you for that. Dont forget Galena is looking for a good pizza place.
Hit em straight Phil. Travel content creator from Galena IL
11/22/25 Came back today and we had the Crunchy Chicken sandwich and the Chicken parm both amazing. Our server Phil is really great.Only thing is I can only give 5 stars. I want to give 10. Atmosphere is fantastic. Galena IL travel content creator. Prices are really great.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$20–30
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Quiet, easy to talk
Nick
31-05-2025
Very good food I am a hot mess Pizza very delicious 10 out of 10
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$30–50
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Group size
2 people
Chelsea
28-05-2025
Great service and food at this location. They have plenty of parking available. Got seated right away and our table was checked on often even though there was only one server on at the time we went. She did a great job! More
C U
20-05-2025
Being born in the Bronx, my childhood set me up with certain expectations for pizza. Sugar River New Glarus executes the little things that make the overall experience and food memorable each and every time we’ve been in the last 5 years. The food, the atmosphere just works and it keeps us coming back. Are there other places to get pizza? Yes. But none of those places have Phill. Phill is why we go out of our way to get some good pizza. I have a call to action for you reading this review. 1- Help me in ensuring they keep the Hot Mess they dropped for the fall on the menu forever.
2- Ask for Phil.
Also, you will not find a better gluten free pizza in WI. Trust me. We have tried. It’s not out there.
Service
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
$10–20
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Noise level
Moderate noise
Recommendation for vegetarians
Highly recommend
Vegetarian offerings
Large vegetarian selection
Dietary restrictions
Best GF in WI. No doubt.
Parking space
Plenty of parking
Parking options
Free parking lot, Free street parking
Kid-friendliness
Big time kid friendly. Jars of letters on each table. Again, Phil fist bumps our kids and is awesome.
Wheelchair accessibility
Yes.
Sheila Rodebaugh
08-04-2025
We did not enjoy anything from this location. Sun prairie location much better. Had to flag our server down to get a drink. Very inattentive to our table. Excessive amount of time to wait for our food. People that sat down after us, … More
Kanekoa Pawn White
19-03-2025
Met up with some old friends! Food was super good, and not too greasy. Left with a full belly and a happy heart! ❤️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
iNguyening Tran
08-03-2025
We ordered the 16” Amazon Deluxe and Yahara Chicken Alfredo pizza. Both were good, but I really like the Amazon Deluxe better. I’m more of the red sauce kinda guy. ONLY one disappointment…I didn’t ordered the thin crust, my bad not the … More
Jessie.M
29-12-2024
Waited for quite a while for a small Caesar salad and an order of the marinara and goat cheese with breadsticks to go, which was fine..but was quite disappointed with the marinara and goat cheese. First photo is what it looks like … More
Reviews Sugar River Pizza Co New Glarus